• Ralphie as Thomas
  • Peter McCallister (from Home Alone) as Henry
  • The Old Man as Gordon
  • Buzz McCallister (from Home Alone) as James
  • Schwartz as Percy
  • Lampie (from Pete's Dragon) as Toby
  • Andrew (from Mary Poppins) as Bertie
  • Budgie (from Budgie the Little Helicopter) as Harold
  • Kara (from Shining Time Station) as Lady
  • The Grinch (from How the Grinch Stole Christmas) as Diesel 10
  • Burton & Earl (from Home Alone) as Splatter & Dodge
  • Didi & Grace (from Shining Time Station) as Annie & Clarabel
  • Emelius Brown (from Bedknobs & Broomsticks) as Sir Topham Hatt (not seen)

The Garfield and Friends Characters as The Shining Time Station Cast

  • Orson as Mr. Conductor
  • Roy as Mr. C Junior
  • Plato as Burnett Stone
  • Cloe as Lily
  • Bo as Patch
  • Lanolin as Stacy Jones
  • Garfield as Billy Twofeathers

Director's Cut Characters

  • Grover Dill as George
  • Big Mickey (from TUGS) as Cranky
  • The Weasel as PT Boomer