Version 1 (made by Vinhchaule)

  • Barney as Homestar Runner
  • BJ as Pom Pom
  • Baby Bop as Marzipan Walker
  • Riff as Homsar Walker
  • Popee (from Popee the Performer) as Strong Bad
  • Pob (from Pob's Programme) as The Cheat
  • The Winkster as Strong Mad
  • Michael as Strong Sad
  • Derek as Homeschool Winner
  • Shawn as Palm Palm
  • Tosha as Homestand Singer
  • Min as Homestarzipan Walker
  • Carlos as Star Bad
  • Danny as Jerry
  • Mr. Boyd as The King of Town
  • Parappa (from PaRappa the Rapper and Playstation All-Stars: Battle Royale) as Coach Z
  • Mr. Tenagain as Bubs
  • Stephen as Gubs
  • Kenneth as Poopsmith
  • Kermit the Frog (from The Muppets and Sesame Street) as Frank Bennedetto