1. Finn
2. Matt Hardy
3. Amethyst
4. Homicide
5. Beast Boy
6. Godzilla
7. Ash Ketchum
8. Sin Cara (Luis Urive)
9. Revy
10. Pinkie Pie
11. Pearl
12. Cyborg
13. Kassius Ohno
14. Kim Possible (Surprise Return)
15. Princess Twilight Sparkle
16. Steven Universe
17. "Almighty" Joe Briscoe
18. Pac Man (Returning from Injury)
19. Discord
20. Gumball Watterson (Returning from Injury)
21. Johnny Test
22. Applejack
23. Mumbo Jumbo (Surprise Return)
24. Mick Foley (Surprise Appearance)
25. Fluttershy
26. Austin Aries
27. Kick Buttowski
28. Nobita Nobi
29. The Incredible Hulk
30. Samurai Jack
31. Omy
32. Android 18
33. Rarity
34. Rainbow Dash
35. AJ Styles (WINNER)
36. Corey Riffin
37. Garnet
38. Robin
39. Rin Okamura
40. Batman (Returning from Inactivity)
ELIMINATION ORDER:
1. Homicide (Eliminated by Finn)
2. Godzilla (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
3. Ash Ketchum (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
4. Steven Universe (Eliminated by Kim Possible)
5. Amethyst (Eliminated by Revy)
6. Kim Possible (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
7. "Almighty" Joe Briscoe (Eliminated by Pac Man)
8. Mumbo Jumbo (Eliminated by Austin Aries)
9. Sin Cara (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno)
10. Mick Foley (Eliminated by Austin Aries)
11. Fluttershy (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
12. Pac Man (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno And Matt Hardy)
13. Discord (Eliminated by Tirek)
14. Kick Buttowski (Eliminated by Android 18)
15. Corey Riffin (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
16. Samurai Jack (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno)
17. Rarity (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno)
18. Garnet (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno)
19. Pinkie Pie (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
20. Pearl (Eliminated by Kassius Ohno)
21. Android 18 (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
22. Nobita Nobi (Eliminated by AJ Styles)
23. Omy (Eliminated by Austin Aries)
24. Beast Boy (Eliminated by Austin Aries)
25. Austin Aries (Eliminated by Cyborg)
26. Cyborg (Eliminated by The Incredible Hulk)
27. Johnny Test (Eliminated by Robin)
28. Applejack (Eliminated by AJ Styles)
29. Rainbow Dash (Eliminated by Matt Hardy)
30. Kassius Ohno (Eliminated by Batman And Robin)
31. Rin Okamura (Eliminated by Batman)
32. The Incredible Hulk (Eliminated by Matt Hardy, Robin, Gumball, And Batman)
33. Princess Twilight Sparkle (Eliminated by Robbie V)
34. Gumball Watterson (Eliminated by Robbie V)
35. Batman (Eliminated by Robbie V)
36. Finn (Eliminated by Robbie V)
37. Robin (Eliminated by Robbie V)
38. Matt Hardy (Eliminated by AJ Styles)
WINNER - AJ Styles