Version 1[]
- Alice (Alice in Wonderland) as Susan Test (Alice and Susan both wear Mary Janes)
- Wart (The Sword in the Stone) as Gil Nexdor (Wart and Gil are both blonde)
- Blue Fairy (Pinocchio) as Fairy Godmother
- Mirage (Aladdin the Series) as Evil Fairy
- Honest John (Pinocchio) as Bling Bling Boy
- Pinocchio (Pinocchio) as Johnny
- Shanti (The Jungle Book) as Mary
- Brer Rabbit (Song of the South) as Dukey
Version 2[]
- Kilala Reno (Kilala Princess) as Susan Test
- Rei (Kilala Princess) as Gil Nexdor
- Duchess (The Aristocats) as Fairy Godmother
- Magica DeSpell (Ducktales) as Evil Fairy
- Kaa (The Jungle Book) as Bling Bling Boy
- Mowgli (The Jungle Book) as Johnny
- Isabella (Phineas and Ferb) as Mary
- Baloo (The Jungle Book) as Dukey
Version 3[]
- Wendy (Peter Pan) as Susan Test
- Peter Pan (Peter Pan) as Gil Nexdor
- Mama Odie (Princess and the Frog) as Fairy Godmother
- Evil Queen (Snow White) as Evil Fairy
- Gideon (Pinocchio) as Bling Bling Boy
- Christopher Robin (Winnie the Pooh) as Johnny
- Jenny (Oliver and Company) as Mary
- Pooh (Winnie the Pooh) as Dukey
Version 4[]
- Lilo (Lilo and Stitch) as Susan Test
- Keoni (Lilo and Stitch) as Gil Nexdor
- Kanga (Winnie the Pooh) as Fairy Godmother
- Gnorga (A Troll in Central Park) as Evil Fairy
- Djon the Thief (Ducktales the Movie) as Bling Bling Boy
- Simba (The Lion King) as Johnny
- Penny (The Rescuers) as Mary
- Timon (The Lion King) as Dukey
Version 5[]
- Minnie Mouse (Mickey Mouse) as Susan Test (Minnie and Susan are both pretty)
- Danny Cat (Cats Don't Dance) as Gil Nexdor (Danny and Gil are both tall and handsome)
- Aurora (Sleeping Beauty) as Fairy Godmother
- Maleficent (Sleeping Beauty) as Evil Fairy
- Sir Hiss (Robin Hood) as Bling Bling Boy
- Bambi (Bambi II) as Johnny
- Daisy Duck (Mickey Mouse) as Mary
- Thumper (Bambi II) as Dukey
Version 6[]
- Olivia (The Great Mouse Detective) as Susan Test
- Fievel (An American Tail) as Gil Nexdor
- Belle (Beauty and the Beast) as Fairy Godmother
- Queen Narissa (Enchanted) as Evil Fairy
- Creeper (The Black Cauldron) as Bling Bling Boy
- Mickey Mouse (Mickey Mouse) as Johnny
- Melody (The Little Mermaid 2) as Mary
- Goofy (Mickey Mouse) as Dukey
Version 7[]
- Namine (Kingdom Hearts) as Susan Test
- Sora (Kingdom Hearts) as Gil Nexdor
- Jasmine (Aladdin) as Fairy Godmother
- Larxene (Kingdom Hearts) as Evil Fairy
- Brer Fox (Song of the South) as Bling Bling Boy
- Cody (The Rescuers Down Under) as Johnny
- Gosalyn Mallard (Darkwing Duck) as Mary
- Piglet (Winnie the Pooh) as Dukey