Cast[]
Version 1[]
- Boomer (from The Fox and the Hound) as Big Bird
- Coloniel Hathi (from The Jungle Book) as Snuffy
- Max (from The Little Mermaid) as Barkley
- Bambi (from Bambi) as Elmo
- Aladdin (from Aladdin) as Bert
- Genie (from Aladdin) as Ernie
- Mufasa (from The Lion King) as Cookie Monster
- Zazu (from The Lion King) as Grover
- Faline (from Bambi) as Zoe
- Doug (from Zootopia) as Oscar the Grouch
- Koda (from Brother Bear) as Baby Bear
- Kronk (from The Emperor's New Groove) as Telly
- Olivia (from The Great Mouse Detective) as Rosita
- Gaston (from Beauty and the Beast) as Count
- Hyenas (from The Lion King) as Bats
- Faline (from Bambi) as Prairie Dawn
- Abby Mallard (from Chicken Little) as Abby Cadabby
- Merlin (from The Sword in the Stone) as Amazing Mumford
- Wendy Darling (from Peter Pan) as Gabi
- Deb (from Finding Nemo) as Dorothy
- Mr. Frederickson (from Up) as Mr. Noodle
- Prince Charming (from Cinderella) as Bob
- Nani (from Lilo and Stitch) as Maria
- David (from Lilo and Stitch) as Luis
- Cinderella (from Cinderella) as Gina
- Roger (from 101 Dalmatians) as Alan
- Princess Tiana (from The Princess and the Frog) as Susan
- Prince Naveen (from The Princess and the Frog) as Gordon
- Arthur (from The Sword in the Stone) as Miles
- Sarabi (from The Lion King) as Celina
- Bellwether (from Zootopia) as Grudgetta
- John Darling (from Peter Pan) as Murray Monster
- Peter Pan (from Peter Pan) as Mr. Hooper
- Michael Darling (from Peter Pan) as Chris
- Cody (from The Rescuers Down Under) as David
- Hercules (from Hercules) as Mr. Handford
- Lost Boys (from Peter Pan) as Sesame Street Kids
- Woody (from Toy Story) as Guy Smiley
- Nala (from The Lion King) as Betty Lou
- Duke Weaselton (from Zootopia) as Frazzle
- Taran (from The Black Cauldron) as Little Jerry
- Audrey (from Home on the Range) as Madame Alma Cluck
- Rafiki (from The Lion King) as Chrissy
- Jaq (from Cinderella) as Joey Monkey
- Gus (from Cinderella) as Davey Monkey
- Filmore (from Cars) as Rockin' Richard
- Prince John (from Robin Hood) as Big Jeffy
- Cows (from Home on the Range) as Cows
- Friend Owl (from Bambi) as Hoots the Owl
- Timon (from The Lion King) as Forgetful Jones
- Sergeant Calhoun (from Wreck-It Ralph) as Clementine
- Bullseye (from Toy Story 2) as Buster the Horse
- Kristoff (from Frozen) as Bert's Train Engineer
- Dinky (from The Fox and the Hound) as Little Bird
- Anna (from Frozen) as Nina
Version 2[]
- Bambi as Elmo
- Faline as Zoe
- Goofy as Big Bird
- Max Goof as Little Bird
- Pooh as Snuffy
- Pluto as Barkley
- Donald Duck as Oscar
- Daisy Duck as Grundgetta
- Aladdin as Bert
- Genie as Ernie
- Mufasa as Cookie Monster
- Zazu as Grover
- Pete as Count
- Beagle Boys as Bats
- Piglet as Baby Bear
- Kessie as Abby
- Clara Cluck as Madame Alma Cluck
- Sarabi as Rosita
- Tigger as Telly
- Chip as Joey Monkey
- Dale as Davey Monkey
- Owl as Hoots the Owl
- Gopher as Forgetful Jones
- Eeyore as Murray Monster
- Lumpy as Buster the Horse
- Christopher Robin as Mr. Hooper
Version 3[]
- Bambi (From Bambi) as Elmo
- Pooh (From Winnie the Pooh) as Big Bird
- Mufasa (From Lion King) as Cookie Monster
- Kenai and Koda (From Brother Bear) as Bert and Ernie
- Iago (From Aladdin) as Grover
- Zazu (From The Lion King) as Kermit the Frog
- Quasimodo (From The Hunchback of Notre Dame) as Mumford
Version 4[]
- Pooh (from Winnie the Pooh) as Big Bird
- Eeyore (from Winnie the Pooh) as Snuffy
- Bambi (from Bambi) as Elmo
- Faline (from Bambi) as Zoe
- Scar (from The Lion King) as Oscar the Grouch
- Aladdin (from Hercules) as Bert
- Genie (from Aladdin) as Ernie
- Mufasa (from The Lion King) as Cookie Monster
- Zazu (from The Lion King) as Grover
- Jafar (from Aladdin) as The Count
- Pongo (from 101 Dalmatians) as Telly
- Perdita (from 101 Dalmatians) as Rosita
- Young Simba (from The Lion King) as Baby Bear
Version 5 (DO NOT CHANGE THIS!!!)[]
- Mickey Mouse as Elmo (both are international superstars with high-pitched voices and are associated with the color red)
- Goofy as Big Bird (both are tall, and talented yet clumsy, and great friends with the superstars)
- Minnie Mouse as Abby Cadabby (both are the superstars' love interests)
- Donald Duck as Grover (both are good friends with the superstars, are associated with the color blue, and are usually not good at helping despite their best efforts)
- Don Karnage as Oscar the Grouch
- Stitch as Cookie Monster (both are blue, furry, and big eaters)
- Jasmine (from Aladdin) as Bert (both are easily flustered and dragged into something they didn't want to do in the first place)
- Ariel (from The Little Mermaid) as Ernie (both are joyful, energetic, friendly, playful, imaginative, and impulsive, and love to play in the water)
- Tigger as the Count
- Pocahontas as Herry Monster (both used to be big stars until their popularities had waned but gained some back when they appeared more prominently)
- Scrooge McDuck as Telly
- Winnie the Pooh as Baby Bear
- Elsa (from Frozen) as Zoe (both females gained popularity at the times they were introduced until fans decided to move on to focus on newer characters)
- Forky as Julia
- Pluto as Tango
- Max Goof as Little Bird
- Terry and Perry (from Monsters University) as the Two-Headed Monster
- Max the Sheepdog (from The Little Mermaid) as Barkley
- Phineas and Ferb as Biff and Sully
- Hiro Hamada as Alan
- Launchpad McQuack as Chris
- Anna (from Frozen) as Nina
- Buzz Lightyear as Gordon
- Jessie as Susan
- Snow White as Maria
- Prince Florian as Luis
- Rodger Radcliffe as Bob
- Anita Radcliffe as Linda
- Cinderella as Gina
- Woody as Miles
- Mirabel Madrigal as Gabi