Cast[]
Version 1[]
- Freddy as Thomas
- Golden Freddy as Edward
- Toy Freddy as Henry
- Foxy as Gordon
- The Puppet as James
- Bonnie as Percy
- Mr. Hippo as Toby
- Endo 01 and Endo 02 as Donald and Douglas
- Chica as Emily
- Toy Freddy as Duck
- Toy Bonnie as Oliver
- Springtrap as Diesel
- Mangle as Mavis
- Circus Baby as Rosie
- Toy Chica as Molly
- Ballora as Daisy
- Nightmare as Diesel 10
- Shadow Freddy and Shadow Bonnie as Arry and Bert
- Henry Emily as Sir Topham Hatt
- Balloon Boy as Billy
Version 2 (By ThomasandFriends7/ToyBonnieFan92)[]
- Bonnie as Thomas
- Toy Bonnie as Edward
- Foxy as Henry
- Freddy as Gordon
- Golden Freddy as James
- Bowser Jr (SML) as Percy
- Toy Freddy as Toby
- Mike Schmidt as Duck
- Funtime Foxy (SL) as Donald (I know FT Foxy is a female)
- Lolbit (SL and FW) as Douglas
- Ennard (SL) as Oliver
- Chica as Emily
- Nightmare Fredbear as Diesel
- Toy Chica as Molly
- Mangle as Mavis
- Ballora (SL) as Belle
- Baby (SL) as Rosie
- Fredbear as Eagle
- Funtime Freddy (SL) as Stanley
- Bon Bon (Bonnie Puppet from SL) as Stepney
- Nightmare Freddy as Diesel 10
- Nightmare Bonnie as Max
- Nightmare Foxy as Monty
- Nightmare Chica as Elizabeth
- Balloon Boy as Skarloey
- The Puppet as Rheneas
- Springtrap as Duncan
- Nightmare Balloon Boy as Smudger
- Nightmare Mangle as Daisy
- Plushtrap as Lorry 1
- Yendo (SL) as Gold Thomas
- Minireena (SL) as Silver Percy
- Nightmarrione as Bronze Diesel
- Nightmare (Animatronic) as Big City Engine
- Bonnet (SL) as Caroline
- Bidybab (SL) as Millie
- Shadow Freddy as The Flying Scotsman
- Phantom Freddy as Ghost Gordon
- Phantom Bonnie (If he existed) as Ghost Thomas
- Phantom Chica as Ghost Emily
- Phantom Foxy as Ghost Henry
Version 3 (by ExaladV3)[]
- Freddy as Thomas
- Toy Bonnie as Edward
- Marionette as Henry
- Fredbear as Gordon
- Foxy as James
- Bonnie as Percy
- Toy Freddy as Toby
- William Afton/Purple Guy as Diesel
- Ballora as Daisy
- Circus Baby as Mavis
- Fredbear Plush as Stepney
- Chica as Emily
- BonBon as Bertie
- Rockstar Foxy as Salty
- Jack o' Bonnie and Jack o' Chica as 'Arry and Bert (genderbent role for Bert)
- Bidybab as Fergus
- Funtime Chica as Lady
- Nightmare as Diesel 10
- Nightmare Freddy and Nightmare Fredbear as Splatter and Dodge
- Mike Schmidt as Sir Topham Hatt
- Nightmare Foxy as Bulgy
- Nightmare Chica as Elizabeth
- Nightmare Bonnie as George
- Nightmare Balloon Boy as S.C. Ruffey
- Phone Guy as Mr. Percival
- Rockstar Foxy's Bird as Harold
- Mangle as Rosie
- Freddles as Troublesome Trucks
- Plushtrap as Smudger
- Funtime Freddy as Stanley
- Dreadbear as D261
- Shadow Freddy as Dennis
- Toy Chica as Molly
- Balloon Boy as Billy
- JJ as Flora
- Twisted Wolf as Alfred
Version 4 (by Jm13740)[]
- Freddy as Thomas
- Toy Bonnie as Edward
- Withered Freddy as Henry
- Golden Freddy as Gordon
- Foxy as James
- Bonnie as Percy
- Toy Freddy as Toby
- Mr. Hippo as Duck
- Funtime Foxy as Donald
- Lolbit as Douglas
- Orville as Oliver
- Chica as Emily
- Phantom Freddy as Diesel
- Endo 01 and Endo 02 as Bill and Ben
- Montgomery Gator as BoCo
- Nightmare Bonnie as The Spiteful Brakevan
- Happy Frog as Mavis
- Funtime Chica as Rosie
- Toy Chica as Molly
- Vanny as Daisy
- Sunrise as Stepney
- Candy Cadet as Bertie
- Glamrock Foxy as Salty
- El Chip as Toad
- Adventure Freddy as Skarloey
- Adventure Bonnie as Rheneas
- Adventure Golden Freddy as Sir Handel
- Adventure Withered Freddy as Peter Sam
- Adventure Toy Freddy as Rusty
- Adventure Foxy as Duncan
- Old Man Consequences as Duke
- Puppet as Freddie
- Adventure Endo 01 and Endo 02 as Mighty Mac
- Redbear as Arthur
- Shadow Freddy and Shadow Bonnie as Arry and Bert
- BonBon as Fergus
- Glamrock Freddy as Murdoch
- Fredbear as Green Arrow
- Glamrock Chica as Lady
- Springtrap as Diesel 10
- Blacklight Freddy and Bonnie as Splatter and Dodge
- Mike Schmidt as Sir Topham Hatt
- Grim Foxy as Bulgy
- Phantom Mangle as Elizabeth
- Ennard as George
- Lefty as Spencer
- Righty as Mallard
- Nightmare Freddy as S.C. Ruffey
- Phone Guy as Mr. Percival
- Rockstar Foxy's Bird as Harold
- Ballora as Belle
- Rockstar Freddy as Flynn
- Rockstar Foxy as Rocky
- Rockstar Bonnie as Butch
- Endos as Troublesome Trucks
- The Blob as Bulstrode
- Plushtrap as Smudger
- Chipper as Cranky
- Funtime Freddy as Stanley
- Dreadbear as D261
- Yenndo as Dennis
- Balloon Boy as Billy
- Circus Baby as Flora
- JJ as Charlie (I know JJ is female)
- Mangle as Marion
- Nedd Bear as Alfred
- Mad Endo as Hector