The Idea was pitched by George Meyer, Bill Oakley and Josh Weinstein, although it was written by Martha Moran. "Me and my Imagination" was written by Matt Warburton. Director Jim Reardon, described the Episode to be a very "Unpredictable" and "Encouraging" thing he worked on.
Madeline: (regarding the Girls' Alien Fantasies) This is too silly. Your imaginations have gone wild.