- Dr. Bunsen Honeydew (from The Muppet Revue) as Ludwig von Drake
- Horatio the Elephant (from Sing Yourself Sillier at the Movies) as Dumbo
- Lightning (from Elmo Saves Christmas) as Bambi
- Prairie Dawn (from Bert and Ernie's Word Play) as Cinderella
- Grundgetta (from Sing Yourself Silly!) as Cruella de Vil
- Kermit the Frog (from The Kermit and Piggy Story) as Prince Charming
- Miss Piggy (from The Kermit and Piggy Story) as Snow White
- The Cat in the Hat (from The Grinch Grinches the Cat in the Hat) as Genie
- Sally (from The Cat in the Hat) as Princess Jasmine
- Conrad (from The Cat in the Hat) as Aladdin
- Elmo (from Learning to Share) as Peter Pan
- Zoe (from Learning to Share) as Tinker Bell
- Foo-Foo (from It's the Muppets!: More Muppets, Please!) as Lady
- Rowlf the Dog (from It's the Muppets!: Meet the Muppets!) as Tramp
- Grover (from Let's Eat: Funny Food Songs!) as Lumiere
- Mr. Johnson (from Let's Eat: Funny Food Songs!) as Cogsworth
- Fozzie Bear (from Fozzie's Muppet Scrapbook) as Bashful
- Benny Rabbit (from 123 Count with Me) as Grumpy
- Zoot (from Muppet Moments) as Sleepy
- Sam-I-Am (from Dr. Seuss on the Loose) as Happy
- Telly Monster (from The Great Numbers Game) as Sneezy
- Lowly Worm (from Richard Scarry's Best Videos Ever) as Dopey
- Jiminy Cricket (from Pinocchio) as Doc
- Big Bird (from Learning About Numbers) as Ichabod Crane
- Charlie Brown (from A Boy Named Charlie Brown) as Mowgli
- Papa Bear (from The Berenstain Bears) as Baloo
- Frazzle (from Monster Hits!) as The Headless Horseman
- Janice (from Rock Music with the Muppets) as Princess Aurora
- Mama Bear (from The Berenstain Bears) as Mrs. Potts
- Brother Bear (from The Berenstain Bears) as Chip
- Bert (from Bert and Ernie's Word Play) as Timon
- Ernie (from Bert and Ernie's Word Play) as Pumbaa
- Princess Melora (from The Frog Prince) as Ariel
- Taminella Grinderfall (from The Frog Prince) as Ursula
- Bugs Bunny (from Space Jam) as Quasimodo
- Lola Bunny (from Space Jam) as Esmeralda
- Animal (from Rock Music with the Muppets) as Beast
- Zelda Rose (from Muppet Treasures) as Belle
- Mad Monty (from Muppet Treasure Island) as Captain Hook
- Clueless Morgan (from Muppet Treasure Island) as Mr. Smee
- Statler and Waldorf (from The Great Muppet Caper) as Tweedle-Dee and Tweedle-Dum
- Little Chrissy and the Alphabeats (from Rock & Roll!) as Donald Duck, Jose Carioca and Panchito Pistoles
- Girl Pirate (from Muppet Sing-Alongs: Muppet Treasure Island) as Pocahontas
- Jim (from Children's Songs and Stories) as Roy E. Disney
- Gonzo (from Gonzo Presents Muppet Weird Stuff) as Mad Hatter
- Fern Arable (from Charlotte's Web) s Alice
- The Evil Queen (from Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs) as The Queen of Hearts
- Rugby Tiger (from The Christmas Toy) as The Cheshire Cat
- Dr. Teeth (from The Muppet Movie) as Johnny Appleseed
- Robin the Frog (from The Muppet Christmas Carol) as Mr. Toad
- Link Hogthrob (from The Muppet Revue) as Casey
- Thomas Twiddlebug (from Elmo's Sing-Along Guessing Game) as Jiminy Cricket
- Father Bunny (from The Tale of the Bunny Picnic) as Geppetto
- Bean Bunny (from The Tale of the Bunny Picnic) as Pinocchio
- Splurge (from Hey, Cinderella!) as Monstro
- Biff (from Sing-Along) as Hercules
- Sully (from Sing-Along) as Philoctetes
- Oscar the Grouch (from Elmo's Sing-Along Guessing Game) as Hades
- Pontoffel Pock (from Pontoffel Pock, Where Are You?) as King Arthur
- Mr. Hoober-Bloob (from The Hoober-Bloob Highway) as Merlin
- Long John Silver (from Muppet Treasure Island) as Sir Kay
- The Stepmother (from Hey, Cinderella!) as Madam Mim
- Peter Cratchit (from The Muppet Christmas Carol) as Young Simba
- Doc Bullfrog (from Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas) as Mufasa
- Snoopy (from Snoopy, Come Home!) as Rafiki
- The Grinch (from Halloween is Grinch Night) as Scar
- The Three Little Pigs (from Learning to Share) as Three Little Pigs
- The Big Bad Wolf (from Learning to Share) as The Big Bad Wolf
- Woodstock (from Snoopy, Come Home!) as Iago
- Captain Hook (from Peter Pan) as Jafar
- Tigger (from Winnie the Pooh) as Robin Hood
- Uncle Deadly (from Monster Laughs with Vincent Price) as Prince John
- Flik (from A Bug's Life) as Cri-Kee
- Polly Lobster (from Muppet Sing-Alongs) as Mushu
- Maureen the Mink (from A Muppet Family Christmas) as Mulan
- Molt (from A Bug's Life) as LeFou
- Hopper (from A Bug's Life) as Gaston
- Max (from The Muppet Movie) as Kaa
- Doc Hopper (from The Muppet Movie) as Shere Khan
- Little Bird (from Sing, Hoot and Howl with the Sesame Street Animals) as The Aracuan Bird
- Sergeant Murphy (from Richard Scarry's Best Videos Ever) as Ranger Woodlore Aubudon
- Lucy van Pelt, Linus van Pelt and Schroder (from A Boy Named Charlie Brown) as Wendy, Michael and John Darling
- Honkers (from Sing Yourself Silly!) as Pink Elephants
- Billy Bunny (from Billy Bunny's Animal Songs) as Brer Rabbit
- Chuck Stoat (from Emmet Otter's Jug-Band Christmas) as Brer Fox
- Too-Tall (from The Berenstain Bears) as Brer Bear
- Baby Kermit, Baby Piggy, Baby Fozzie, Baby Animal, Baby Scooter, Baby Skeeter, Baby Rowlf and Baby Gonzo (from Muppet Babies) as Dalmatian Puppies
- Sweetums (from The Muppet Movie) as Paul Bunyan
- The Martians (from Elmo's Sing-Along Guessing Game) as Chip 'n' Dale
- Mother Cat (from Richard Scarry's Best Videos Ever) as Kanga
- Huckle Cat (from Richard Scarry's Best Videos Ever) as Roo
- Herry Monster (from Monster Hits!) as Tigger
- P.J. (from It's Not Easy Being Green) as Piglet
- Baby Bear (from Do the Alphabet) as Winnie the Pooh
Dr. Bunsen Honeydew: Where does everyone sit? Let me see... Hmm...
We got Horatio to the left, and we got Lightning to the right,
then Prairie Dawn, and Grundgetta, and Kermit the Frog and Miss Piggy.
The Cat in the Hat's next to Sally and Conrad and his lamp,
along with Elmo and Zoe and Foo-Foo and the Rowlf the Dog.
Here's Grover the blue monster, and Mr. Johnson, he's the customer,
There's Fozzie, Benny, Zoot, Sam-I-Am, Telly Monster, Lowly Worm, Jiminy Cricket.
Table Nine has Big Bird, by Charlie Brown and Papa Bear,
Frazzle's Table Seven, and his head's at Table Two.
Over here is Janice. Ooh, someone wake her up!
From Beauty and the Beast, we got Mama Bear and Brother Bear.
Bert and Ernie, Princess Melora, and Taminella Grinderfall in her shell,
Bugs Bunny's next to Lola Bunny, Animal is next to Zelda Rose.
Mad Monty, now here's where he goes, here's where Clueless Morgan goes.
Statler and Waldorf goes right behind Little Chrissy and the Alphabeats.
Girl Pirate, that's where she goes, by Jim, that's where he goes,
'Cause movie stars have egos and you gotta treat 'em right!
Gonzo's next to Fern Arable, The Evil Queen and Rugby Tiger,
Dr. Teeth and Robin the Frog and Link Hogthrob and his bat.
Thomas Twiddlebug and Father Bunny and Bean Bunny, little elf!
And Splurge in the corner gets a table to himself.
We got Biff, Sully, and Oscar the Grouch next to him,
Pontoffel Pock's next to Mr. Hoober-Bloob and Long John Silver's by the Stepmother.
There's Peter Cratchit by Doc Bullfrog and Snoopy next to the Grinch,
Three Little Pigs, the Big Bad Wolf, Woodstock and Captain Hook.
Tigger, Uncle Deadly, Flik, Polly Lobster, and Maureen the Mink.
Here's Molt and there's Hopper, then there's Max and here's Doc Hopper.
And the crazy Little Bird, and here's Sergeant Murphy,
we got Lucy van Pelt, Linus van Pelt, Schroeder, I could just go on and on!
Honkers, Billy Bunny, and Chuck Stoat and Too-Tall.
Here are some cute Muppet Babies-Whoop! They need another chair!
Sweetums, The Martians, and then there's Mother Cat and there's Huckle Cat...
Right next to Herry and to P.J. and to Baby - He's the Bear.