• Bert as Sam the Eagle
  • Sherlock Hemlock as Jean Pierre Napoleon
  • Oscar the Grouch as Constantine
  • Zoe as Miss Piggy
  • Grover as Gonzo
  • Prairie Dawn as Camilla
  • Forgetful Jones as Lew Zealand
  • Count von Count as Dr. Teeth
  • Biff as Dr. Bunsen Honeydew
  • The Amazing Mumford as The Swedish Chef
  • Sully as Beaker
  • Frazzle as Animal
  • Honkers as Penguins
  • Ernie as Fozzie Bear


Bert: Big Bird, let's begin
Describe the day you played Berlin
Oscar the Grouch (pretending to be Big Bird): We rehearsed and then we walked about
We ate bratwurst and sauerkraut
Sherlock Hemlock: That night, at 10:03
Were you inside the portrait gallery?
Oscar the Grouch: From 10:00 to 10:04
Was when we did the show's encore
Bert: Hm, bird, we've got our doubts
Can you confirm your whereabouts?
Oscar the Grouch: My alibi is watertight
The audience saw me sing all night
Sherlock Hemlock: Monsieur, we know you did the crime
Oscar the Grouch: I was onstage that whole time
Ask who sang Rainbow Connection.
Bert and Sherlock Hemlock: Thank you, Big Bird! No more questions!
Sherlock Hemlock: Hello! I think it's time for good cop/romantic cop.
Zoe, you cleaned up lock inside
Now's your chance to save your hide
Zoe: Oh, gentlemen, I did not know
It's a crime to steal the show
Bert: Tell us how the art was taken
Sherlock Hemlock: If you want to save your bacon
Zoe: I haven't seen your missing art
All I stole was audience hearts
Bert: We can give you a plea deal
Sherlock Hemlock: All you have to do is squeal
Zoe: I'm not a thief, I don't know how
All I've ever taken is a bow
Sherlock Hemlock: We'll catch the swine that did this job
Zoe: Give up the pig puns, creep!
Go jump in a lake, that's my suggestion!
Bert and Sherlock Hemlock: Thank you, Zoe! No more questions!
Sherlock Hemlock (spoken): I think she likes me, no?
Bert (spoken): I don't think your puns are helping the investigation.
Sherlock Hemlock: You know, I think they did it
Bert: No, they didn't!
Sherlock Hemlock: Yes, they did, and we can pin it
Bert: If they did, how did they do it?
Sherlock Hemlock: If they didn't, how did they didn't?
Bert: If they didn't, then it's easy
'Cause they simply didn't do it
Sherlock Hemlock: If they did it, then I knew it
But we've nothing that can prove it!
(spoken): Ahem. Oh excuse me. Bring in the blue guy with the schnoz.
Bert: Do you remember what you did
On the night you played Madrid?
Grover: I was hit by a raging bull
And rushed off-stage to the hospital
Sherlock Hemlock: Grover, what do you know
About the sculpture theft at Madrid's Prado?
Grover: I never saw the stolen bust
I spent the night in bed concussed
Bert: The truth, Grover, the clock is ticking
Grover: If you don't believe me, ask the little girl
Prairie Dawn was there, she'll cooperate
Sherlock Hemlock: Madam, are you willing to corroborate?
Prairie Dawn: (clucking)
Bert: Will somebody get this girl out of here?
Grover: Calm down, Prairie Dawn, it's a routine inspection
Bert and Sherlock Hemlock: Thank you, Grover! No more questions!
Sherlock Hemlock: Let's go from the start
What do you know about the stolen art?
Forgetful Jones: I didn't know there was a plan
Count von Count: Your accusation's far out, man!
Biff: The chances of us committing a crime
Are less than .009
The Amazing Mumford: (Faux-Swedish)
Sherlock Hemlock: To help with our investigation
Can you do a full translation?
Translator/Sully: What the chef just said to you was "Shnoopdy-shnoopdy-shnoo." It's not Swedish.
Frazzle: (grunts and laughs)
Honkers: (honking)
Ernie: Uh, I can do an Elvis impression
Bert and Sherlock Hemlock: Thank you, Muppets! No more questions!
Sherlock Hemlock: They didn't
Bert: No, they didn't
Sherlock Hemlock: There's no way they did the crime
Bert: They couldn't, they're too stupid
Sherlock Hemlock: They're not criminal masterminds
Bert: We do not know who did it
But we know they didn't do it
Sherlock Hemlock and Bert: So we know who didn't do it
Yes, we know who didn't do it!
Sherlock Hemlock (spoken): They're incapable of being culpable.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.