Version 1 (made by UbiSoftFan94)

  • Ten Cents as Toaster
  • Warrior as Lampy
  • Sunshine as Blanky
  • Big Mac as Kirby
  • Top Hat as Radio
  • Big Mickey as Air Conditioner
  • Lillie as Chris
  • Digby (from Theodore Tugboat) as Robby
  • Coast Guard as Baby Robbie
  • Hercules as Plugsy
  • Diesel 10 (from Thomas) as The Evil Clown
  • Bluenose as Elmo
  • Zip as Elmo's Dog
  • Dead Disney Characters as Junkyard Cars
  • Zorran as The Giant Magnet
  • Carl (Lillie's boyfriend) (made up TUGS characters) as Cutting-Edge Computer
  • Other Tugboats as Other Appliances

Version 2 (made by JosephCL93)

  • Sally Seaplane as Toaster
  • Pugwash (from TT) as Blanky
  • Ten Cents as Lampy
  • Zebedee as Kirby
  • Sunshine as Radio
  • Big Mickey as Air Conditioner (Coast Guard can't be Air Conditioner, Coast Guard is small and Air Conditioner is tall)
  • Thomas (from Thomas) as Robby
  • Emily (from Thomas) as Chris
  • Nantucket as The Evil Clown
  • Grampus's Dad (made up TUGS Characters) as Plugsy
  • Big Mac as Mack
  • Bluenose as Elmo
  • Coast Guard as Elmo's dog
  • Rheneas (from Thomas) as Baby Robbie
  • and more