The Best of Schemer is a fan-made Shining Time Station US DVD idea made by BiggestThomasFan. It features one Season 1 episode, one Season 2 episode and three Season 3 episodes.
- Too Many Cooks
- Field Day
- Schemer Alone
- Schemer's Robot
- Schemer's Special Club
- Gordon Takes a Dip (Ringo Starr) (Too Many Cooks)
- Down the Mine (Ringo Starr) (Too Many Cooks)
- Percy Proves a Point (George Carlin) (Field Day)
- Thomas and Bertie's Great Race (George Carlin) (Field Day)
- Percy, James and the Fruitful Day (George Carlin) (Schemer Alone)
- Tenders and Turntables (George Carlin) (Schemer's Robot)
- Trouble in the Shed (George Carlin) (Schemer's Robot)
- Oliver Owns Up (George Carlin) (Schemer's Special Club)
- Bonus Schemer Presents! Short: How to Get Something Done
- Thomas Stories told by Ringo Starr and George Carlin.
- Schemer and Schemee from "Field Day"
- James and Percy at Tidmouth Sheds from the story "Percy, James and the Fruitful Day"
- Schemer and Robby the Robot from "Schemer's Robot"