• Bart Simpson as Peter Pan
  • Laura Powers as Wendy
  • Milhouse Van Houten as John
  • Ralph Wiggum as Michael
  • Homer Simpson as George Darling
  • Marge Simpson as Mary Darling
  • Santa's Little Helper as Nana (I know, SLH is male)
  • Lisa Simpson as Tinkerbell
  • Jessica Lovejoy as Tiger Lily
  • Nelson Muntz as Cubby
  • Jimbo Jones as Slightly
  • Rod and Todd Flanders as The Twins
  • Martin Prince as Nibs
  • Maggie Simpson as Tootles (I know Maggie is Female)
  • Sideshow Bob as Captain James Hook
  • Cecil Terwilliger as Mr. Smee
  • Snake Jailbird as Tick-Tock the Crocodile
  • Mayor Quimby as Indian Chief