• Bart as Pinocchio
  • Homer as Geppetto
  • Grandpa Abe as Jimmy Cricket
  • Milhouse as Figaro
  • Marge as Cleo
  • Edna Krabappel as The Blue Fairy
  • Aliens as The Donkeys
  • Citizens of Springfield as The Seagulls
  • Goombas (from Mario) as The Coachman's Minions
  • Mr. Burns as Honest John
  • Jimbo as Gideon
  • Nelson as Stombroli
  • Dolph as Lampwick
  • Sideshow Bob as Monstro The Whale
  • Snake Jailbird as The Wicked Coachman