Cast:
Version 1 (Made By UbiSoftFan94 akaRayFan94)
- Thomas as Peter Pan (Thomas and Peter Pan are both the main heros)
- Emily as Wendy (Emily has a crush on Thomas, just like Wendy has a crush on Peter Pan)
- Duck as John Darling (Duck and John Darling are both Western)
- Percy as Micheal Darling (Percy and Micheal Darling are both small)
- Mavis as Tiger Lily (Tiger Lily's Black Hair does match with Mavis' Coat of Paint)
- Lady as Tinker Bell (Lady and Tinker Bell are both magical)
- Gordon as George Darling (Gordon and George Darling are both proud, but sometimes grumpy)
- Molly as Mary Darling (Molly and Mary Darling are both have the letter 'M')
- James as Slighty (James and Slighty are both vain)
- Rosie as Nana (Nana's voice suits Rosie)
- Harvey as Chubby (Harvey and Chubby are both brown)
- Donald and Douglas as The Twins (All twins)
- Salty as Nibs (Nibs's voice suits Salty)
- Billy as Tootles (Tootles's voice suits Billy)
- Flora, Belle, Caitlin, and The Coaches as The Mermaids
- Boco as The Indian Chief (Boco and The Indian Chief are both wise)
- Daisy as Squaw (Daisy and Squaw are both have 5 words in 1 name)
- Devious Diesel as Captain James Hook (Dievious Diesel and Captain Hook are both the main villains and Captain James Hook's Black Hair does match with Devious Diesel's Coat of Paint)
- Dennis as Mr. Smee (Mr. Smee's voice suits Dennis)
- Arry, Bert, Splatter, Dodge, Paxton and Norman as The Pirates
- Smudger as Tick Tock Crocodile (Smudger and Tick Tock Crocodile are both green and evil)
- D261 as Singing Pirate
- Edward as Edward (Edward and Edward are both share the same names)
- Ashima as Jane
- Bertie as Danny
- Hector as Octopus (Hector and Octopus are both half bad and half good)
Version 2 (made by Josephcl93 and BramGloatFilms)
- Thomas the Tank Engine as Peter Pan
- Emily the Beautiful Engine as Wendy
- Whiff the Rubbish Engine as John
- Percy the Small Engine as Michael
- Lady as Tinker Bell
- Gordon the Big Engine as Mr. Darling
- Diesel 10 as Captain Hook
- Splatter & Dodge as Mr. Smee
- Dennis the Lazy Diesel as The Singing Pirate
- Derek the Diesel as Tick-Tock The Crocodile
- D261 (aka The Diesel) as Mr. Starking
- Henry the Green Engine as Lost Boy Bear
- Mavis the Diesel as Mrs. Darling
- James the Red Engine as Lost Boy Fox
- Bill & Ben as Lost Boy Raccoons
- Neville the Black Engine as Lost Boy Rabbit
- Bertie the Bus as Lost Boy Skunk
- Arry, Bert & Trucks as Pirate Chews
- Cranky the Crane as Indian Chef
- Rosie the Tank Engine as Tiger Lily
- Narrow Gauge Engines as Indians
- Elizabeth as Squawk
- Donald & Douglas as Chinese Boy (deleted scene)
- Annie, Clarabel, Millie, Daisy and Coaches as Mermaids
- Gremlin as Nana
- Molly the Yellow Engine as Jane
- Edward the Blue Engine as Dad
- Bulstrode the Barge as Octopus
- Toad as Danny
- Duck the Western Engine as Robin Willams Lost Boy
- Boco the Diesel as Roy Disney
and more